Cell Phones As Evidence in Personal Injury Cases

Cell Phones As Evidence in Personal Injury Cases

People have been taking photos and videos on their cell phones since the 1990s, mostly sharing for fun and making memories. Cell phones today play larger and larger roles in daily life. They can even help people capture crimes in pictures or videos in an instant. If you realize you are witnessing a potential crime in St. Petersburg, likely your cell phone will be a lot handier than a “regular” full-size camera. People are starting to grasp the significance of how they can help assist others in a moment of need by using cell phones as evidence.

Assault on Elderly Man

On October 25, in Winter Haven, Florida, a 90-year-old man was backing out from his parking space in a Publix lot about 4:50 in the afternoon. A black four-door vehicle was driving in the parking lot, in the wrong lane. The 90-year-old victim had looked in both directions to ensure it was safe for him to back out of his parking space, when, BAM! The black vehicle (which may have been a Kia) slammed into him. Both drivers got out of their cars and proceeded to yell and curse at each other. There was also a passenger in the black vehicle, who got out of the car and was yelling as well, when, all of a sudden, one of the occupants of the black vehicle hit the 90-year-old man so hard, it knocked him unconscious.

It was reported that several people were in the vicinity during this time, and one witness even tried to stop the occupants of the black vehicle from speeding off after the assault, but was unable to do so. Police are asking for the public’s help to identify the occupants of the black vehicle. It is thought that at least one person might have taken a video of the incident. This is where everyday citizens can step up and help solve cases like this, especially when there is unnecessary brutality involved. With that being said, it is also important to keep calm and quiet, trying to take pictures or video unobtrusively, as no one would want an innocent bystander to get hurt “because” they were trying to record an event. Use commonsense and, when possible, if you are witness to an incident, if you can take pictures or a video that could be useful later, don’t hesitate to use the smart technology at hand to help another.

Importantly, for intentional acts, such as assault and battery, the defendant may be open to punitive damages without caps and cannot simply avoid the judgment by declaring bankruptcy.

Photos and Videos

Photographs and videos have become two of the most effective pieces of evidence that can be presented in court. In fact, in car accidents and many other types of accidents, it is unusual NOT to have photos or videos presented as evidence. Of course, before cells phones as evidence can be entered, either photos or videos, they must pass the authentication test. Questions that will be asked include:

• Does the photo accurately represent the subject?
• Does the photo or video fairly represent the subject?

Issues remain that could cause the photo or video to be admissible, or inadmissible, in court. The question will also arise:

• How relevant is the picture and how does that weigh against an undue prejudice on a party?

Photos and videos submitted as evidence could also raise challenges due to the ease with which photos and videos can be altered. The angle and light in photos and videos could also be called into question to address the pertinence of the evidence. Many variables could come into play; however, it is still considered very helpful to have this kind of material available for use. If you or a loved one have been involved in an accident or incident where cell phone photos and/or videos may have been taken, speak with a personal injury attorney about potential acceptance of that material as crucial evidence in your case.